skip to main content skip to footer

Coming Soon

Be sure to join our mailing list to receive

exclusive offers and news

Join Our Mailing List

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

* Please let us know if you have a severe allergy and we will do our best to accommodate you.

Dinner Menu



Locally sourced and imported European farm cheeses, Air Cured Meat and Dry Sausage, Hudson Valley Orange Ricotta, Artisan Olives.

One $12 | Two $18 | Three $24 | Four $30

$141839 Brine Smoked Wings

Gluten Free

Slow Backyard Smoked Wings, Habañero Mango Glaze, Smoked Bleu Crumbles, Boom Dip, House Pickles. 10 each

$12Steamed Buns

Braised Pork Shoulder, Bulgogi Glaze, Pickled Veg, Toasted Benne

$15Line Caught Seared Tuna Poke


Avocado, Pineapple Salsa, Cucumber,
Wasabi Aioli, Soy Glaze, Crispy Wontons

$12Skillet Bread


Fig Jam, Arugula, Asiago, Extra Virgin Olive Oil.

$12Cheese and Macaroni

Four Cheese Fondue, Slightly Burnt Slab Bacon, Ritz Cracker Parm Crust

$13French Onion Purses


Handcrafted French Onion Wonton Purses, Broiled Gruyère

$10Vegan Chili Verde

Vegan | Gluten Free

Tomatillo, Chickpea, Market Veg, Butternut Squash, Toasted Mediterranean Spices

Blue Point Oysters**

Minimum 3 per order*


Cocktail Sauce and Mignonette

$3 each


Horseradish Sauce, Chilled Vodka, Caviar – Contains Alcohol

$5 each


Ikura -Salmon Caviar and Mignonette. 

$4 each


Add a Side to Your Salad:
Simply Grilled All-Natural Chicken $6 | Gulf of Maine Honey Ginger Salmon  $7

$14Tuscan Panzanella


Heirloom Tomato and Chickpea Salad, Chargrilled Baby Romaine with Caesar Drizzle, Creamy Burrata Cheese, Sourdough Croutons and Balsamic Reduction

$141839 Smokey Bleu


Romaine, Avocado, Heirloom Tomato, Roasted Sweet Corn, Black Bean, Smoked Bleu Cheese, Crispy Tortilla, Rumble Sauce

$14Hudson Valley Farm-to-Table


Our daily repertoire of the finest produce. Each individual item is Grilled, Roasted or Marinated into delicious expressions of the season.

$6Simple House Salad

Vegetarian | Vegan | Gluten Free

Baby Artisan Greens and Garnishes


$23Wild Caught Caramelized Shrimp

Gluten Free

Brotherhood Sherry, Slow Smoked Local Bacon, Cheddar Grits, Brussels Salad, Goshen's Cabot Butter

$19Cast Iron Chicken Breast

Gluten Free

Hot Pan Seared All-Natural Chicken,
Kabocha Squash, Today's Veg, Pan Jus

$21Brotherhood Style Hot Chicken

Crispy Fried, Bourbon Barrel Maple, Mikes Hot Honey and Cinnamon Mascarpone. With a side of our Cheese and Macaroni, Belgian Waffle and House Pickles.

$23Gulf of Maine Salmon

Honey Ginger Glaze, Scallion Potato Pancake, Bok Choy

$29Certified Angus New York Strip Steak

Gluten Free

Aged for Twenty-Four Days, Yukon Gold Mash, Gremolata, Today's Veg

12 oz.

$16The Raclette Burger*

Iowa Premium Certified Angus Chuck, Caramelized Onion, House Pickles, Signature Sauce, finished with Tableside Broiled Raclette Cheese. Served on Brioche with House Fried Kettle Chips

$21Braised Short Rib Ravioli

Truffle Cappuccino Sauce, Crispy Parsnips

$15Harvest Pasta

Vegan | Vegetarian

Fresh Made Garganelli, Seasonal Veg, Caramelized Shallots, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Fresh Herbs

Burrata $6 | Simply Grilled All-Natural Chicken $7 | Seared Wild Caught Shrimp $8


$8Milkshake and Cookies

Fresh Baked Chocolate Chunk, Kahlúa Milkshake – Contains Alcohol

$8Classic Crème Brûlée


Vanilla Custard, Caramelized Sugar

$8Brotherhood Poached Pear

Spiced Brotherhood Wine, Vanilla Bean Gelato, Biscotti

$8Flourless Chocolate Tort

Gluten Free

Raspberry Coulis

$8Aunt Dot’s Strawberry Shortcake


Brown Butter Cake, Fresh Cream, Strawberry

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

* Please let us know if you have a severe allergy and we will do our best to accommodate you.

Dinner Drink Menu

House Wines

Casas Patronales

Cabernet Sauvignon

6 oz. $6 |10 oz. $10 | Bottle $18


6 oz. $6 |10 oz. $10 | Bottle $18

Sauvignon Blanc

6 oz. $6 |10 oz. $10 | Bottle $18


From The Winery

Cabernet Sauvignon


6 oz. $9 |10 oz. $14 | Bottle $27

Cabernet Sauvignon

1839 Brotherhood

Bottle $50



6 oz. $9 |10 oz. $14 | Bottle $27


Brotherhood -The Blue Bottle

6 oz. $8 |10 oz. $13 | Bottle $25


Casas Patronales RESERVA

Bottle $22


Casas Patronales RESERVA

Bottle $22

Cabernet Sauvignon

Casas Patronales RESERVA

Bottle $22


Casas Patronales RESERVA

Bottle $22

Sauvignon Blanc

Casas Patronales RESERVA

Bottle $22

Other Reds

Cabernet Sauvignon, Gravel Bar

Columbia Valley, WA ’16

6 oz. $11|10 oz. $15 | Bottle $32

Zinfandel, Shooting Star

Mendocino County, CA '12

6 oz. $11 |10 oz. $15 | Bottle $32

Pinot Noir, Firesteed

Willamette Valley, OR ’17

6 oz. $11 |10 oz. $15 | Bottle $32

Rosso, Saladini Pilastri

Piceno, Italy '12

6 oz. $10 |10 oz. $14 | Bottle $28

Other White

Pinot Grigio, Torresella

Veneto, Italy ’17

6 oz. $11|10 oz. $15 | Bottle $28

Sauvignon Blanc, Kono

Marlborough, NZ ‘17

Bottle $32


Sparkling Rosé

Brotherhood Winery

Bottle $27

Dry Rosé

Brotherhood Winery

6 oz. $9|10 oz. $14 | Bottle $27

Babe Rosé

With Bubbles - Can Rosé

6 oz. $8


Blanc De Blancs

Brotherhood Sparkling Wine

6 oz. $8  | Bottle $27

Dessert Wine

Ruby Port


6 oz. $8| Bottle $24

1839 Cocktails

$11Purple Rain

Acai Blueberry Vodka, Triple Sec, Cranberry Juice – Martini Glass

$12Coconut Margherita

1800 Coconut Tequila, Coconut Cream, Lime Juice, Pineapple Juice, Coconut Rim

$12Susan Jean

Brotherhood Blanc de Blancs, St. Germain Elderflower Liqueur, Muddled Cherry, Fresh Thyme, Candy Cranberry Rim

$12Rockaway Sour

Bulleit Bourbon, Solerno Blood Orange Liquor, Sour Mix, Club Soda

$12Citrus Negroni

Deep Eddy True Lemon Vodka, Campari, Sweet Vermouth, Orange Wheel

$10The MacLeod

Jameson, Neat

Brotherhood Seasonal Sangria

All depends on what’s churning out of the Winery. Ask your server!

Glass  $8 | Pitcher  $24

$10Fresh off the Press

Tito’s Vodka, Muddled Cucumber and Mint, Lime Juice, Ginger Ale, Club Soda, Crystal Mint Rim

$11The Morning After

1839 Bloody Mary

Draft Beer

Merman IPA

Coney Island Brewery, 5.8%

Small 12oz. $6 |  Large 16oz. $8

Köld One Kölsch

Mill House Brewing Co.,  4.6%

Small 12oz. $7 | Large 16oz. $9

Cream Ale

Newburgh Brewing Co., 4.2%

Small 12oz. $5 | Large 16oz. $7

Brown Ale

Roscoe Beer Co., 5.5%

Small 12oz. $5 | Large 16oz. $7

Bottles and Cans

$6Fat Tire Amber Ale

$4Bud Light

$6Captain Lawrence

Hop Commander IPA

$4Coors Light

$5Shock Top Belgian White

$5Angry Orchard

Crisp Apple Cider

$6Stella Artois

$6Modello Especial


$8Babe Rosé

With Bubbles




Espresso, Mezcal Tequila, Kahlua, Fresh Cream

$3Bigleow Tea




Coffee, Jameson, Bailey’s, Fresh Cream

Water and Soft Drinks

$6Saratoga Spring Water

28 oz.

$2Iced Tea


$2 Lemonade

$4Ginger Beer